The all-but-certain influence of our final defeat in Afghanistan on Vladimir Putin’s decision to invade Ukraine was just one link in a long chain of consequences forged by the Iraq war. It’s now clear that not just the war alone but its ever-spreading secondary consequences - which included our futile overinvestment in Afghanistan, fatefully cast as the “good war” by many Democrats opposed to the Iraq invasion - kept us tied us down during critical years of geopolitical realignment, making it hard to even think about, let alone cope with the revival of Russian power and the rise of China to superpower status. ![]() ![]() Bush’s platform in 2000, before he traded his humble foreign policy for a grand crusade.īut it is in the effect on America’s global position that the costs of the Iraq war really keep compounding. ungovernable and incapable of governing.Īnd there is a special irony that even with the intellectual ferment on the Trump-era right, the attempts to forge a “national conservatism” or a socially conservative populism, sometimes look like efforts to grope backward to George W. Ever since the war discredited both neoconservatism specifically and the Republican establishment generally, nobody has been able to maintain a successful counterweight to the various forms of right-wing populism, Tea Party and Trumpian, that have made the G.O.P. Ever since the war discredited and helped dissolve the hawkish center-left, nobody has been able to reconstitute a strong centrist faction within liberalism, with the result that liberal institutions have been pulled ever leftward since 2004. In our political coalitions, these disillusioning effects look even more substantial and permanent than they appeared in 2010 or 2015. Its lingering effects have made the body politic more susceptible to left-wing radicalism and right-wing demagogy, while contributing to a persistent mood of pessimism and disappointment that’s then been exacerbated by other forces (social media, the coronavirus pandemic). The war’s influence has percolated inside other social crises, like the opioid epidemic, that have become more visible and destructive over time. In American domestic life the Vietnam effect was more of a fever, whereas the Iraq effect seems like a wasting or relapsing disease. As a squandering of blood and treasure and moral credibility, but one whose overarching strategic costs were not so great.īut today there’s a stronger case for seeing Iraq as a more epochal disaster. As a bad war, but not an era-defining one. When Barack Obama was elected president, American conservatism seemed shattered by Iraq, as American liberalism was shattered by Vietnam, but by his second term there was a return to ideological stalemate.Īt various times, then - at the 10th anniversary of the war, maybe even at the 15th - it was possible to imagine a long-term future where Iraq was ultimately remembered more like our bloody counterinsurgency in the Philippines at the dawn of the 20th century than like the trauma of Vietnam. The immediate aftermath of Iraq was sour and paranoid in its own way, but even with the Great Recession there wasn’t the same kind of radicalism and social breakdown. ![]() The United States lost the Vietnam War completely in Iraq we left behind an unsteady and corrupt republic rather than a new dictatorship, with a government that still allows an American military presence.ĭomestically, the period around the Vietnam War was dreadful - a wave of domestic terrorism, a crisis of authority, the 1960s curdling into the 1970s. The bloodletting among Iraqis was terrible, but so was the civilian toll in Southeast Asia. More than 12 times as many American troops died in the Vietnam War as died in Operation Iraqi Freedom and its aftermath. This makes it a useful moment to compare the two conflicts and their effects, and to consider - provisionally, always provisionally - which was more disastrous, which intervention deserves to be remembered as the worst foreign policy decision in our history.įor some time, even after my own initial support for the war dissolved and its folly became obvious, I doubted that Iraq could outstrip Vietnam in the ranks of American debacles. At the 20th anniversary of the Iraq war, we stand in the same position relative to the initial invasion as America stood in 1985 relative to the 1965 arrival of our first combat troops in Vietnam.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |